Medical Malpractice Implications of Expanded Practice for NPs and PAs

In recent years, some states have broadened nurse practitioners’ (NPs) and physician assistants’ (PAs) scope of practice. With this change, as well as the increased use and role expansion of NPs and PAs during the COVID-19 crisis, there is a growing interest in what the implications might be on clinical practice—or patient safety—as well as medical malpractice, specifically underwriting and claims management.

To better understand the risks and vulnerabilities, we have run multiple queries on our national Comparative Benchmarking System (Candello) data to learn more. As it specifically relates to the topic of NPs and PAs, we can analyze different aspects such as:

  • Is the rate of NPs and PAs named in a medical malpractice claim changing?
  • How does the rate of NPs and PAs named in a medical malpractice claim compare to the rate of physicians named?
  • Are there any emerging trends related to NPs and PAs?
  • Are there implications for underwriting or claims management in how they underwrite and/or defend these professionals?
  • What are the clinical risk mitigation opportunities to reduce medical malpractice claims involving NPs and PAs?

WHAT DOES THE DATA TELL US?

Growth rates of licensed NPs and PAs in the United States, as reported by professional organizations for the five-year period ending in 2019, were 41% for NPs and 37% for PAs. As of December 31, 2019, total licensed NPs equaled 290,000 and PAs 140,000.

Licensed Nurse Practitioners and Physician Assistants
in 2019 Compared to 2014

 

2014

2019

% Change

Nurse Practitioners Licensed 1,2

205,000

290,000

41%

Physician Assistants Licensed 3,4

102,000

140,000

37%

 

Candello data enables us to look at this broadly or drill down into a specific area of interest. In a recent review of these practitioners, growth and claim trends were analyzed. In a review of nearly 100,000 cases* in the Candello database, NPs and PAs are most often named as a defendant alongside their physician colleagues (with or without the organization named).Pie chart representing the percent of NPs and PAs named in MPL Claims: 42% named with MDs and Org.; 27% named along; 12% named with Org., and 19% named with MDs

On our upcoming member Candello Underwriting Study Group call, a group comprising underwriting professionals from across the country and Puerto Rico, we will discuss this topic. We have worked with our data analysts to see what our national Candello data show and will explore this topic in more depth on the call.

Candello Members who missed the call on August 18 at 1:00 PM ET and can learn more about the call in the online Candello Community.

Resources

  1. More Than 290,000 Nurse Practitioners Licensed in the United States
  2. Nurse Practitioner Ranks Continue to Grow
  3. National Commission on Certification of Physician Assistants Annual Report: 2014 Statistical Profile of Certified Physician Assistants
  4. National Commission on Certification of Physician Assistants Annual Report: 2019 Statistical Profile of Certified Physician Assistants
Written By
Melissa_Kemp_web
Melissa Kemp, CPA
Melissa is Vice President of Underwriting for CRICO and is responsible for developing underwriting strategy and driving implementation of strategic and operational objectives. She oversees underwriting policy development, risk assessment, and risk intelligence gathering in response to emerging and existing risks.
X
Cookies help us improve your website experience.
By using our website, you agree to our use of cookies.
Confirm